- Sanitation systems
- Water supply
- Groundwater (pollution, management, usage)
- Elevated nitrate concentrations in groundwater - causes and health implications
Elevated nitrate concentrations in groundwater - causes and health implications
26.1k views
![](/templates/protostarsusanawebmix/images_forum/large-icons/33.jpg)
- joeturner
-
Less
- Posts: 717
- Karma: 23
- Likes received: 185
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar2608.jpg)
See this fact sheet from the WHO:
www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/dwq/...atenitrite2ndadd.pdf
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
does anybody know the relationship of nitrate and nitrite in groundwater? While nitrate is not particularly toxic, nitrite is highly toxic, and nitrite is derived from nitrate by reduction (removal of oxigen in an oxigen depleted environment). So, nitrate can be a source of nitrite, isn't that the main danger of nitrate?
Thanks,
H-A
M.Eng. Environmental Pollution Control
presently in Seesen, Germany
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- kevintayler
-
- I am a water and sanitation engineer, also interested in general urban housing issues. In recent years, I have worked on FSM for various organizations
Less- Posts: 79
- Karma: 11
- Likes received: 46
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar4280.jpg)
Independent water and sanitation consultant
Horsham
UK
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- jankn
-
Topic AuthorLess
- Posts: 35
- Karma: 8
- Likes received: 21
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar3378.jpg)
Yeah, this is the one I tried to summarize in my last post which looked at nitrate and E. coli among others. Since it is not the published "journal version", I think it can be shared here; although this might be a bit of a grey area that is, however, widely utilized.
Is the 2015 paper also available as softcopy on the author's website?
Doctoral Researcher on environmental performance assessment and modeling of on-site wastewater treatment systems
Trinity College Dublin & University of Limerick
Email: jan.knappe(at)tcd.ie, Twitter: @JanKnappe
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
I have that paper from the Indian Institute of Science Bangaluru. The copy is not from the Journal, it is from the author available at the web site. It is based on the results of ground water pollution in Kolar District, Karnataka State. Same is attached.
regards
pawan
Chairman
Foundation for Environment and Sanitation
Mahavir Enclave
New Delhi 110045, India
Web: www.foundation4es.org
Linked: linkedin.com/in/drpkjha
This message has an attachment file.
Please log in or register to see it.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- Elisabeth
-
- Moderator
- Freelance consultant since 2012 (former roles: program manager at GIZ and SuSanA secretariat, lecturer, process engineer for wastewater treatment plants)
Less- Posts: 3372
- Karma: 54
- Likes received: 931
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar52.jpg)
I actually had it on my to-do list for a while to ask people on this forum about this (it might warrant a separate thread?). In particular people who have worked in Bulgaria and Romania might be able to tell us more because that's where I saw this link stated from publications of Women in Europe for a Common Future (WECF) for example.
See e.g. this publication:
Buitenkamp, M., Richert Stintzing, A. (2008). Europe's sanitation problem - 20 million Europeans need access to safe and affordable sanitation. Women in Europe for a Common Future (WECF), The Netherlands
www.susana.org/en/resources/library/details/1317
See page 10:
When I visited villages in our project
regions in Romania and Bulgaria these last
months, I still hear from the Romanian
doctors that babies fall ill with blue baby
disease from too high nitrates in the
drinking water. When we test nitrates,
far too often we find such excessive levels
in drinking water, 10 times more than the
maximum allowed. These nitrates are not
caused by excessive fertilizer usage, but
by infiltration of faeces into drinking water
wells, both animal dung as well as human
faeces from unsealed latrines, latrines
which are often close to wells.
I got onto this topic via a discussion with Joe and other editors of the Wikipedia article on Blue Baby Syndrome. Please see our conversation here on the talk page of this article:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Blue_baby_syn...me_has_been_disputed
I used to think it was a well established clear link but after reading that I realised it's not so clear cut.
Joe had written on the talk page:
I am in no sense an expert, but I'd just note that the link between nutrient enrichment and human health has been disputed to my knowledge for at least 20 years, so I support what User:Jermakka has said above. It seems to me that there is very little evidence of a direct link between blue baby syndrome and nitrates, most of the talk about it is spurious. It is one of those internet memes which are repeated without any real scientific basis, as far as I can see. JMWt (talk) 07:25, 13 May 2015 (UTC)
One thing that had always puzzled me is that the safe nitrate level in drinking water is actually quite high - 50 mg/L NO3 (this is for the molecule NO3, not for N like wastewater engineers prefer as a measurement unit). See e.g. here for England and Wales:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_Supply_(Wate..._(England_and_Wales)
So I am also thinking that nitrate in groundwater is not really a primary health concern, at least not compared to pathogens. But I would be keen to hear what other people know or have read about the issue of nitrate in drinking water.
Regards,
Elisabeth
Freelance consultant on environmental and climate projects
Located in Ulm, Germany
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
My Wikipedia user profile: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:EMsmile
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/elisabethvonmuench/
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- joeturner
-
Less
- Posts: 717
- Karma: 23
- Likes received: 185
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar2608.jpg)
In general, in an unsaturated soil, pollutants become more diluted and less concentrated with depth, depending on the soil texture (which related to the pores).
The problem is that real-world situations frequently do not match calculated conditions. One reason is because soil conditions can change in certain conditions - for example some clay soils will swell in certain conditions, leading to large channels through which fluids and pollutants can flow via something called bypass flow. This can mean that in certain circumstances pollutants move through the soil much more quickly than might be expected on paper. Vertical movement of pathogens is going to depend on the flow of water, which again will depend on conditions and soil type (including how big the pathogen cells are relative to the soil pores etc). So I don't think it is fair to suggest that there is a general rule.
Direct health effects of nitrates are highly disputed, however it is certainly true that there are environmental impacts of nitrate enrichment, which can indirectly lead to health impacts.
For me, the presence of pathogens is by far a bigger problem than the presence of nitrates - although the chemical measurement of nitrogen enrichment is an easier thing to measure than the presence of pathogens, so I think it is a reasonable suggestion that high concentrations of nitrate strongly suggest the possibility of pathogen movement as well.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- kevintayler
-
- I am a water and sanitation engineer, also interested in general urban housing issues. In recent years, I have worked on FSM for various organizations
Less- Posts: 79
- Karma: 11
- Likes received: 46
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar4280.jpg)
Nitrate does provide an indication that pollution from pits and soakaways is present (although the source might also be agricultural fertilizers). However, it will be more persistent than pathogens and the presence of nitrogen does not necessarily indicate that pathogens are present.
Others may wish to add their thoughts to this. For an introductory explanation of the effects of nitrate on drinking water see psep.cce.cornell.edu/facts-slides-self/f.../nit-heef-grw85.aspx
Independent water and sanitation consultant
Horsham
UK
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- jankn
-
Topic AuthorLess
- Posts: 35
- Karma: 8
- Likes received: 21
Re: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar3378.jpg)
Unfortunately, we only have the hardcopy subscription here which has not arrived yet (the latest issue has just been published); but I'll give it a read and let you know once I got a hold on the article.
But I know that the same group of researchers from IISc (Indian Institute of Science) has been looking at the relation of leaching pit latrines and groundwater quality for quite a while now. They have performed studies in Mulbagal, Karnataka, India. There is a paper "Impact of pit-toilet leachate on groundwater chemistry and role of vadose zone in removal of nitrate and E-coli pollutants in Kolar District, Karnataka, India" published in 2013. Again, the article is behind a pay wall and can be found here . I so hope, that more institutions and projects progress to open access publications!
Anyway, they were looking at groundwater samples from 69 drinking water wells in the area and compared different types of pollution within the city limits to the background concentration in rural areas and concluded that infiltration from pit toilets has contaminated drinking water wells. Looking at nitrate concentrations they found 148 mg/l (mean) within the city, and 30 mg/l outside the city, compared to a permissible limit of 45 mg/l. E. coli load was 189 MPN/100ml (mean, 55% of wells were contaminated) inside and nearly no E. coli contamination outside the city (9% of wells were contaminated with a mean of 1 MPN/100ml). They concluded that the unsaturated zone (soil above the groundwater) can remove 1 log E. coli every 4 m (Note: this really depends on the soil; Mulbagal has a rather sandy soil. In a more organic and clayey soil, the removal would be better.) and, thus, wells with a water table lower than 25 m below surface would be pathogen free, but not necessarily nitrate free (if properly constructed, of course).
And while we're at it, there is an aged, but nevertheless informative IRCWD review article about the risk of groundwater pollution by on-site sanitation in developing countries by Lewis et al. (1982) here for those who have not seen it yet.
Doctoral Researcher on environmental performance assessment and modeling of on-site wastewater treatment systems
Trinity College Dublin & University of Limerick
Email: jan.knappe(at)tcd.ie, Twitter: @JanKnappe
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar845.jpg)
Sounds like a very interesting article. Do they substantiate the claim that nitrogen pollution of aquifers is a big problem with any data / estimates in the full text? (I can't get the article, therefore I am asking you.
Regards
Marijn
E: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- jankn
-
Topic AuthorLess
- Posts: 35
- Karma: 8
- Likes received: 21
Elevated nitrate concentrations in groundwater - causes and health implications
![](/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size200/users/avatar3378.jpg)
This thread is focussing on nitrate and is a spin-off thread of this thread with the title "Ground water pollution from leach pit toilets (question from India)":
forum.susana.org/forum/categories/193-gr...-question-from-india
++++++++++++
This maybe touches only a certain part of the issue, but in the recent issue of the IWA Journal of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene for Development researchers from IISc Bangalore looked at the potential of permeable reactive barriers to mitigate groundwater nitrate contamination from on-site sanitation.
Abstract: "Nearly 50% of India's population depends on variants of pit-toilet systems for human waste disposal. Nitrate contamination of groundwater by pit-toilet leachate is a major environmental concern in the country as it sources a major proportion (50–80%) of potable water from aquifers. Therefore, minimizing nitrate contamination of groundwater due to leachate infiltration from pit-toilet systems is essential. Batch and column experiments demonstrated the capability of bentonite-enhanced sand (BES) specimens to reduce nitrate concentrations in synthetic solutions (initial NO3-N concentration = 22.7 mg/L, C/N = 3) by about 85–90% in 10 to 24 hour by a heterotrophic denitrification process. Based on the laboratory results, it is recommended that use of a BES-permeable reactive barrier layer at the base of pit-toilets will facilitate heterotrophic denitrification and mitigate nitrate contamination of the underlying aquifer."
The full article is behind a pay wall and can be found here .
Doctoral Researcher on environmental performance assessment and modeling of on-site wastewater treatment systems
Trinity College Dublin & University of Limerick
Email: jan.knappe(at)tcd.ie, Twitter: @JanKnappe
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- Sanitation systems
- Water supply
- Groundwater (pollution, management, usage)
- Elevated nitrate concentrations in groundwater - causes and health implications