- Forum
- categories
- Sanitation systems
- Toilets with urine diversion
- UDDTs (urine-diverting dry toilets)
- PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
13.7k views
Re: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Thanks Joshua. We have received a tiny amount of money to research if this is possible, I have written a bit on my blog: indiebio.co.za/growing-fungal-mycelium-on-faeces
The following user(s) like this post: joshuaurieli
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Thanks indiebio for the response and question. I have since moved on to different projects in a different industry. However I am more than happy to support any further research remotely with my experience. I would be happy to share my field notes along with the details of my preliminary research. Feel free to contact me directly if you interested in using mushrooms in your sanitation research.
The following user(s) like this post: evemackinnon7
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
This is wonderful Joshua, thank you for sharing! If work using this would gain traction again, would you be keen to get involved again?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Thanks for the comment Tore. The oyster mushroom fruit is edible and highly nutritious. Theoretically the fruit of oyster mushrooms used for treating human faeces could be eaten.
Source: www.smithymushrooms.co.uk/
However there are some practical issues with the idea:
- Ensuring that the oyster mushroom fruit is well cleaned
- Ensuring that no pharmaceuticals (antibiotics, hormone treatments, etc..) are taken up by the mushroom from the faeces
- Convincing people that it is a good idea to eat mushrooms grown on poop
More feasible would be to:
- Leave the mushrooms in your compost as a fertiliser
- Feed the oyster mushroom fruit to livestock
This does not stop you buying some oyster mushrooms from another source and frying yourself up a delicious meal.
Source: www.thedailymeal.com/grilled-oyster-mushrooms-recipe
Source: www.smithymushrooms.co.uk/
However there are some practical issues with the idea:
- Ensuring that the oyster mushroom fruit is well cleaned
- Ensuring that no pharmaceuticals (antibiotics, hormone treatments, etc..) are taken up by the mushroom from the faeces
- Convincing people that it is a good idea to eat mushrooms grown on poop
More feasible would be to:
- Leave the mushrooms in your compost as a fertiliser
- Feed the oyster mushroom fruit to livestock
This does not stop you buying some oyster mushrooms from another source and frying yourself up a delicious meal.
Source: www.thedailymeal.com/grilled-oyster-mushrooms-recipe
Attachments:
-
GrilledOys...ooms.jpg (Filesize: 52KB)
-
OysterMushrooms.jpg (Filesize: 79KB)
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply- Tore
-
- worked in sanitation for most of my life. taught plumbing. have plumbing and builders license, certified inspector in all facets of construction, PhD in public administration & have taught construction management in university, traveled numerous countries, Interest UDDT and sanitation & clean water
Less- Posts: 75
- Karma: 2
- Likes received: 27
Re: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Is there anyway that the mushrooms could be made edible considering the toxic location?
Sanitation & water consultant in developing countries
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Thanks for the questions Kris!
1. I did not test urine in the paper bag extensively. With one hand made prototype I filled it with increasing amounts of water. From memory: it held fine with 2/3 litres of water, became unstable with 5-6 litres, and broke with 8 litres. However this prototype was made with "water resistant" paper. The intention was to eventually use a paper coated with biodegradable plastic, however I never sourced or tested this material.
2. The oyster mushrooms will impact the downstream treatment. Whether the impact is positive or negative will depend on the downstream treatment process. For composting the impact would theoretically be positive as the mushrooms help to treat the faeces, and adds carbon content to the mixture. However, I never tested this theory.
1. I did not test urine in the paper bag extensively. With one hand made prototype I filled it with increasing amounts of water. From memory: it held fine with 2/3 litres of water, became unstable with 5-6 litres, and broke with 8 litres. However this prototype was made with "water resistant" paper. The intention was to eventually use a paper coated with biodegradable plastic, however I never sourced or tested this material.
2. The oyster mushrooms will impact the downstream treatment. Whether the impact is positive or negative will depend on the downstream treatment process. For composting the impact would theoretically be positive as the mushrooms help to treat the faeces, and adds carbon content to the mixture. However, I never tested this theory.
The following user(s) like this post: jkeichholz, JKMakowka
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Looks like an excellent and cheap packaging. Two questions though:
- Did you do any tests on how well the paper bags deal with the occasional urine getting into the feces compartment?
- Do you think the oyster mushrooms could impact any downstream treatment facilities (composting?)
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyRe: PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Not gonna lie, Joshua, I really love your post. Content-wise interesting, but especially the way you put it together and share the knowledge and experiences you´ve accumulated!
It works really well as a teaser that makes me want to read the thesis (which is very nicely designed, btw) and the other attachements.
Thanks for sharing this here!
It works really well as a teaser that makes me want to read the thesis (which is very nicely designed, btw) and the other attachements.
Thanks for sharing this here!
The following user(s) like this post: Elisabeth
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to replyPooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Dear Forum
During my masters research (2015-16), I found that Oyster Mushrooms can stop human faeces smelling! My research focused on container based sanitation systems using urine diversion dry toilets. By adding Oyster Mushroom mycelium to the faeces container it is possible to control the smell indefinitely. The result of my masters was PooPac, a bioactive paper bag (containing oyster mushroom mycelium) that suppresses the toilet smell. The biodegradable PooPac is sealed for transport, and directly composted, removing all contact with faeces.
Top: The PooPac as delivered with mushroom cover material. Middle: The Poopac as when in use, shown inside a MoSan toilet. Bottom: Full and sealed PooPac ready for composting.
Masters thesis pdf document
Slide deck that gives a brief overview of the masters project
After my masters was completed I spent another half year looking into using oyster mushrooms to control the smell of feaces. There is some indication that by adding certain chemicals, mushrooms could also work in a standard pit latrines. Furthermore, a literature review and unpublished experiments suggest that mushroom mycelium reduces the pathogens in faeces. Oyster Mushrooms have been shown to reduce the population counts of E. coli and other indicator species.
Top: Section cut of a PooPac in use as exhibited at ZHdK. Bottom: WSUP employee explaining how to use the mushroom cover material in a MoSan toilet, in Kisumu, Kenya.
Mushroom technology literature review
Due to lack of funding and other issues, I have moved on to other projects. So, I would like to share the research, so that anyone in the Susana community may take the work further. Detailed test results and field notes are available on request.
This project was made possible through collaboration with:
The Zurich University of Arts(Zürcher Hochschule der Künste - ZHdK)
MoSan
WSUP
Impact Hub Zurich
I would also like to thank the following organisations for their open interviews and site visits:
Sanivation
Sanergy
EAWAG
X-Runner
Kompotoi
A special thanks to Mona Mijthab, Katie Whitehouse, and Leon Deverick for their collaboration.
I am happy to answer any questions you may have.
Kind Regards,
Joshua Urieli
poopac.ch
During my masters research (2015-16), I found that Oyster Mushrooms can stop human faeces smelling! My research focused on container based sanitation systems using urine diversion dry toilets. By adding Oyster Mushroom mycelium to the faeces container it is possible to control the smell indefinitely. The result of my masters was PooPac, a bioactive paper bag (containing oyster mushroom mycelium) that suppresses the toilet smell. The biodegradable PooPac is sealed for transport, and directly composted, removing all contact with faeces.
Top: The PooPac as delivered with mushroom cover material. Middle: The Poopac as when in use, shown inside a MoSan toilet. Bottom: Full and sealed PooPac ready for composting.
Masters thesis pdf document
This attachment is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.
Please log in or register to see it.
Slide deck that gives a brief overview of the masters project
This attachment is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.
Please log in or register to see it.
After my masters was completed I spent another half year looking into using oyster mushrooms to control the smell of feaces. There is some indication that by adding certain chemicals, mushrooms could also work in a standard pit latrines. Furthermore, a literature review and unpublished experiments suggest that mushroom mycelium reduces the pathogens in faeces. Oyster Mushrooms have been shown to reduce the population counts of E. coli and other indicator species.
Top: Section cut of a PooPac in use as exhibited at ZHdK. Bottom: WSUP employee explaining how to use the mushroom cover material in a MoSan toilet, in Kisumu, Kenya.
Mushroom technology literature review
This attachment is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.
Please log in or register to see it.
Due to lack of funding and other issues, I have moved on to other projects. So, I would like to share the research, so that anyone in the Susana community may take the work further. Detailed test results and field notes are available on request.
This project was made possible through collaboration with:
The Zurich University of Arts(Zürcher Hochschule der Künste - ZHdK)
MoSan
WSUP
Impact Hub Zurich
I would also like to thank the following organisations for their open interviews and site visits:
Sanivation
Sanergy
EAWAG
X-Runner
Kompotoi
A special thanks to Mona Mijthab, Katie Whitehouse, and Leon Deverick for their collaboration.
I am happy to answer any questions you may have.
Kind Regards,
Joshua Urieli
poopac.ch
Attachments:
-
IMG_7098_2...2-07.JPG (Filesize: 119KB)
-
PooPac_003...2-07.jpg (Filesize: 109KB)
-
PooPac_005...2-07.jpg (Filesize: 74KB)
-
PooPac_002...2-07.jpg (Filesize: 85KB)
-
IMG_5609_2...07-3.JPG (Filesize: 172KB)
The following user(s) like this post: jkeichholz, Elisabeth, canaday, Marijn Zandee, JKMakowka, elizabethtilley, magato, Nantik
Please Log in to join the conversation.
You need to login to reply
Share this thread:
- Forum
- categories
- Sanitation systems
- Toilets with urine diversion
- UDDTs (urine-diverting dry toilets)
- PooPac: Using Oyster Mushrooms to stop human faeces smelling in UDDTs - A Masters Thesis
Time to create page: 0.424 seconds