×
Notice
THE FORUM IS IN READ ONLY MODE. We migrate our server. We hope that everything will run smoothly and that we will be fully functional by the middle of next week.
- Forum
- categories
- Resource recovery
- Fertiliser, soil conditioner, production of crops
- Urine reuse or infiltration
- Urine infiltration : how to avoid over-fertilisation?
Urine infiltration : how to avoid over-fertilisation?
4618 views
- mwink
-
Less
- Posts: 41
- Karma: 3
- Likes received: 14
Re: Urine infiltration : how to avoid over-fertilisation?
Dear Geoffrey,
in our own research project, we fertilised with 3-4l of urine per m². This amounted to an N concentration of 69-92 kg N/ha. If I assume now that a German person excretes 1.2l of urine per day I need 110-146m² per person and year.
That's not a lot in agriculture but a lot (as you already mentioned) for private gardens or green areas around an office building.
To answer your first question: Yes, you need a farmer who takes the urine or you need a treatment system to get the nutrients out of the urine. E.g. P can be extracted by an struvite precipitation process and N via stripping. Then the question is: Is the fertiliser you produce still competitive on the market.
See e.g. this study: www.susana.org/lang-en/library?view=ccbk...p;type=2&id=1221
Regarding the addition of urine to compost, let me quote Hakan Jönsson, Prof. of the Agricultural University of Uppsala:
Yours, Martina.
in our own research project, we fertilised with 3-4l of urine per m². This amounted to an N concentration of 69-92 kg N/ha. If I assume now that a German person excretes 1.2l of urine per day I need 110-146m² per person and year.
That's not a lot in agriculture but a lot (as you already mentioned) for private gardens or green areas around an office building.
To answer your first question: Yes, you need a farmer who takes the urine or you need a treatment system to get the nutrients out of the urine. E.g. P can be extracted by an struvite precipitation process and N via stripping. Then the question is: Is the fertiliser you produce still competitive on the market.
See e.g. this study: www.susana.org/lang-en/library?view=ccbk...p;type=2&id=1221
Regarding the addition of urine to compost, let me quote Hakan Jönsson, Prof. of the Agricultural University of Uppsala:
Question two: I guess that alternatives will come up - extracting nutrients and using those within industrial processes. But till now, we haven't done this step besides some first lab-scale experiments. At least, I am not aware of such processes.I discourage from using the urine in a compost, if you can use it in the field instead. A compost is hot, ventilated and has a fairly high pH, normally around 8. This means that a lot of the ammonia, normally more than 50% will be lost to the air, where it is a acidifying and eutrophying emission. Furthermore, you will need a lot of wood chips or straw.
Yours, Martina.
Research unit Water infrastructure and risk analyses
Institute for Social-Ecological Research (ISOE)
Frankfurt, Germany
winker[AT]isoe.de
www.isoe.de
www.saniresch.de
Institute for Social-Ecological Research (ISOE)
Frankfurt, Germany
winker[AT]isoe.de
www.isoe.de
www.saniresch.de
Urine infiltration : how to avoid over-fertilisation?
Dear all,
I hope my question will not seem out of the theme, and someone could reply
I Assume that a person produces about 2.8-3kg of N per year through urine, and plants require about 200 kgN/ha (*), the surface to irrigate would be about 150m² per person. This is context-specific, probably that a tree will consume more N, that in tropical climate where you can grow 3 crops per year.., the quantity of N produced is likely to be fewer, etc.
Ok could we say it needs at least 30m² ou even 10m² per person/student/dweler etc. How to find so much place?
-> Question : How to avoid over-fertilisation and groundwater pollution?
The problem/solution in term of nutrient seems to be in the urine. If there is not enough space to use such concentrated-readily-available-nutrients in such amount, the solution wouldn't it be to find a farmer who could use such rich fertilizer adequately?
-> Question :Or the fixation of nutrients in compost-toilet would be a good solution?
But in compost-toilet with big capacity the urine is either drained (contaminated urine infiltrated on a little area : pollution?) or evaporated (requiring energy and loosing the nutrients, at least N).
In the bucket-compost-toilet, as far as I know there is always liquid (urine) remaining on the bottom. Then The bucket is returned over a compost pile (about 1m³ for a family). Let's say there is no contamination under the compost (which I think should be discussed) : what to do with such a compost? How to avoir over-fertilization and then pollution?
Question : is there any ecological alternative to re-introduce it to crop-production by real farmers?
Thank you in advance for your comments,
and Sory for my so-poor english I hope I could be understood
Yours,
Geoffroy
I've been asked to introduce myself :
I'm bio-engineer, studied soil and water pollution issues, teached them in a belgian school, was trainee in niger and bukina in development sector, worked as wetland contractor/builder in belgium, closely intersted in ecosan/susan issues for several years, now working in wastewater and drinking water treatment sector, and a bit in biogas, and member of an group here in belgium aimed at promoting sustainable santation solutions (no fixed name yet).
(*)In the transposition of Nitrate-Directive, the max application in cultivated land is 250 kgN/ha and max 170kgN/ha if in a sensitive are in terme of N polllution.
I hope my question will not seem out of the theme, and someone could reply
I Assume that a person produces about 2.8-3kg of N per year through urine, and plants require about 200 kgN/ha (*), the surface to irrigate would be about 150m² per person. This is context-specific, probably that a tree will consume more N, that in tropical climate where you can grow 3 crops per year.., the quantity of N produced is likely to be fewer, etc.
Ok could we say it needs at least 30m² ou even 10m² per person/student/dweler etc. How to find so much place?
-> Question : How to avoid over-fertilisation and groundwater pollution?
The problem/solution in term of nutrient seems to be in the urine. If there is not enough space to use such concentrated-readily-available-nutrients in such amount, the solution wouldn't it be to find a farmer who could use such rich fertilizer adequately?
-> Question :Or the fixation of nutrients in compost-toilet would be a good solution?
But in compost-toilet with big capacity the urine is either drained (contaminated urine infiltrated on a little area : pollution?) or evaporated (requiring energy and loosing the nutrients, at least N).
In the bucket-compost-toilet, as far as I know there is always liquid (urine) remaining on the bottom. Then The bucket is returned over a compost pile (about 1m³ for a family). Let's say there is no contamination under the compost (which I think should be discussed) : what to do with such a compost? How to avoir over-fertilization and then pollution?
Question : is there any ecological alternative to re-introduce it to crop-production by real farmers?
Thank you in advance for your comments,
and Sory for my so-poor english I hope I could be understood
Yours,
Geoffroy
I've been asked to introduce myself :
I'm bio-engineer, studied soil and water pollution issues, teached them in a belgian school, was trainee in niger and bukina in development sector, worked as wetland contractor/builder in belgium, closely intersted in ecosan/susan issues for several years, now working in wastewater and drinking water treatment sector, and a bit in biogas, and member of an group here in belgium aimed at promoting sustainable santation solutions (no fixed name yet).
(*)In the transposition of Nitrate-Directive, the max application in cultivated land is 250 kgN/ha and max 170kgN/ha if in a sensitive are in terme of N polllution.
Geoffroy Germeau
Share this thread:
- Forum
- categories
- Resource recovery
- Fertiliser, soil conditioner, production of crops
- Urine reuse or infiltration
- Urine infiltration : how to avoid over-fertilisation?
Time to create page: 0.067 seconds