SuSanA - Forum Kunena Site Syndication Sat, 22 Oct 2016 01:47:19 +0000 Kunena 1.6 SuSanA - Forum en-gb Re: Struvite reactor For Festival in France - by: ben
1) As mentionned, the festival was organized by the communist party, so I call them the Comrads ... just a joke so.
2) We do have a couple of farmers accepting our urine in our homeland, in the south of France montpellier, but around Paris we don't have yet a re-use site. So unfortunatly all the urine was then thrown in the sewer.
3) We established a partnership with WC Loc, french leader of toilet renting (40% of the national market). They wanted for a long time shift to dry toilets systems but it was literaly impossible for their staff to deal with wood dust. So they welcomed very warmly our separation system with conveyor for several reasons :

  • The fact there's no emptying before 50 000 uses is ecnomicly very interesting for them
  • No electric or sewer connection is very interesting too
  • Only one person dealing with more than 15 cabins (cleaning / recharge of paper and gel) makes loads of savings
  • Obvioulsy communication on the ecological move

Paris has recently commited to place only ecological toilets in all the events next year, if the intention is proven in Public bidding soon there's good chances that WC Loc will renew it's park with a decent quantity of our systems. That would be a big shift for autonomous toilet market in france, stoping the sterile war between dry toiletes and plastic cabin renters that has lasted far too long.

The goal at ecosec is to democratized ecological sanitation, and we don't beleive this is possible if our solutions are not economicly competitive. We beleive with the reduction of manwork managing the cabins we can compete with other technologies.

Thanks for your interets
Best ,

Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Wed, 21 Sep 2016 19:37:42 +0000
Re: Struvite reactor For Festival in France - by: muench Thanks for this post, very interesting!

Just a couple of short questions:
  1. What did you mean by "the comrads"?
  2. What did you do with the urine liquid after treatment, i.e. after the phosphorus has been removed from the liquid. It is still high in nitrogen, so did you treat it further or just let it go to the sewer?
  3. How was this demonstration project funded?

Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Wed, 21 Sep 2016 13:02:01 +0000
Struvite reactor For Festival in France - by: ben
We're very happy to share with you the first Struvite reactor we constructed this summer dedicated to the Festivals.
This reactor is fully automized, can remove phosphorus from urine at a rate of 200 l/urine per hour.
We inaugurated it 2 weeks ago at the "Fête de l'huma", 600 000 people in 3 days in Paris organised by the communist party.
Inspired from a similar kind of event made in Amsterdam, see here:

, the comrads, after being sensibilized on the phosphorus end, the nitrate cycle and the benefits of dry toilets systems, were given a little bag of struvite with the inscription "UriBoost, when urine becomes fertilizer"
We "treated" about 2 m3 of urine collecting about 2 kg struvite over the 3 days. People were super pleased, this was all great fun to be honnest. Paris townhall is interested in re-using it when ever they can.
Sorry the comunicatiuon is all in French ... we're working on it.

Our design was based on the previous work on the subject of Bastian Etter, special thanks to him.

Happy to discuss about if you have question.


Ben, from Ecosec]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Wed, 21 Sep 2016 09:40:39 +0000
Formal introduction of SASTEP project on the forum - by: swoolley
Title of grant: South African Sanitation Technology Demonstration Programme (SASTEP) – Reinvented Toilet Technology Demonstration and Roadmap to Commercialization

Name of lead organization: Water research commission (WRC); Department of Science and Technology (South Africa) (WRC is the lead organization in this case although our official designation in the project is ‘implementing agent’, and the project is a partnership between WRC, DST and BMGF)

  • Primary contact at lead organization: Jay Bhagwan / Stuart Woolley
  • Grantee location: Pretoria, South Africa
  • Developing country where the research is being tested: South Africa
  • Start and end date: 25 Nov 2014 to 30 Nov 2018
  • Grant type: Other
  • Grant size in USD: From the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation: 1 million USD (as per grant database: plus funding by the South African Department of Science and Technology (DST): The DST has committed ZAR 30 million (~US$ 3.0 million) over two years to fund the implementation and field-testing of innovative sanitation technologies and approaches in South Africa.


(i) To test the latest in cutting-edge non-sewered sanitation technologies that eliminate faecal sludges and promote resource efficiency; ii) Assess and evaluate for feasibility of widespread use and commercialisation in South Africa; iii) Provide safe and adequate sanitation facilities, particularly in undeveloped rural areas which lack infrastructure.

Objectives of SASTEP:

i) Demonstrate technologies in phases; ii) Provide hard evidence on performance; iii) Provide hard evidence on impact; iv) Iterative feedback to technology developers; v) Catalyse and orient sanitation industry towards water saving and beneficiation systems.

Objectives of the RTTC (Reinvent the Toilet Challenge of the Gates Foundation):

• Disinfect human waste • Recover resources from human waste • Less than US$ 5 cents per user per day • ‘Off the grid’ • Self sufficient
For details see:

Short description of the project:

The Department of Science and Technology (DST) South Africa and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) recently announced a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) – “Partnership in the Demonstration of Sanitation Solutions in Rural and Peri-Urban South Africa” at The Reinvent the Toilet Challenge Fair in Delhi, India. The MoU outlines the cooperation between the two organisations towards achieving sanitation delivery through the implementation / application of innovative sanitation solutions.

The DST has committed ZAR 30 million (~US$ 3.0 million) over two years to fund the implementation and field-testing of innovative sanitation technologies and approaches in South Africa. The technologies to be demonstrated were developed through the BMGF’s Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WSH) programme, in particular, those from the BMGF’s Reinvent the Toilet Challenge. The BMFG WSH programme is contributing US$1 million to support the testing of technologies selected. The lessons learnt through the demonstration of these solutions will be shared with the global community.

The South African Water Research Commission (WRC) will serve as the implementing agent for the demonstration programme. Enquiries of interest are welcomed to potential BMGF grantees who feel that their technologies are ready for demonstration.

Two technologies from the RTTC have been confirmed for installation in 2016:

1. Caltech: Self-contained, PV-powered domestic toilet and wastewater treatment system (

2. Critical Practices: EarthAuger urine-diverting dry toilet (UDDT), see here on the Forum: Two-hundred units have been delivered to South Africa and will be ready for use by mid-2016.

Previous discussion on forum about EarthAuger toilet in Ecuador:

SASTEP is not limited to these two technologies, as SASTEP aims to demonstrate up to five technologies over the duration of the programme. RTTC innovators* who have a near-final product or processing unit (back-end treatment system) are welcome to contact Mr.Stuart Woolley.

Research or implementation partners: The organizations whose technologies were selected for demonstration

Links, further readings – results to date:

Current state of affairs:

The first technology to be demonstrated is the EarthAuger. 200 EarthAuger unitswere in South Africa and and transported to the a rural municipality where the demonstrations are taking place. SASTEP is engaging in community work in order to ensure the acceptance of the technology to aid the success of the demonstration programme.
After the initial demonstration of a few months, we'll see if the units need any further development or if they're suitable to proceed to a more widespread demonstration in other rural areas that don't have experience with similar programmes.

For technologies where the demonstrations are successful (w.r.t. performance, user acceptance and suitability) we will begin a process of developing a strategy for commercialisation, localisation of manufacturing, and otherwise stimulate the local private sectors for uptake of these technologies.

Biggest successes so far:

Mobilising rural communities to accept and support the demonstration programme, achieved through rigorous social interaction and facilitation.

Main challenges / frustration:

Importing of new technologies for demonstration which are not classifiable by national bureaus of customs and excise.

* "RTTC innovators" is defined here specifically as those developers that were a part of the original BMGF Reinvent the Toilet Challenge. Technology developers of similar technologies would be able to negotiate with us directly for opportunites to demonstrate under other programmes with other sources of funding.

Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Tue, 06 Sep 2016 10:46:01 +0000
ADPL (Anaerobic Digestion Pasteurization Latrine) Duke Biogas toilet - by: kathyjooss
Title of grant: ADPL (Anaerobic Digestion Pasteurization Latrine) Duke Biogas toilet

Subtitle: Further development of the Anaerobic Digestion Pasteurization Latrine, a simple, energy neutral self-contained sanitation technology relying on anaerobic digestion and heat pasteurization of the treated effluent.

  • Name of lead organization: Duke University
  • Primary contact at lead organization: Aaron Forbis-Stokes
  • Grantee location: Durham, NC, USA
  • Developing country where the research is being tested: Units are currently being tested in Kenya, India and the Philippines.
  • Start and end date: November, 2015 – March, 2017
  • Grant size: $ 341,337 (see BMGF grant database here)

Short description of the project:

This is a continuation of the research begun in 2011 which was funded by a previous GCE grant. In this phase, it is our objective to fully assess the potential of the ADPL to meet the Foundation’s criteria for Reinvented Toilets. We are intensifying monitoring efforts of our current five ADPL units in Kenya, India and the Philippines, improving implementation and operation, and redesigning the heat pasteurization system for improved efficacy and reliability.


Provide a sanitation system for an extended household of 5-30 users based on an anaerobic digester that produces sufficient biogas to heat pasteurize the daily effluent flowing out of the digester. Sufficient biogas production and an efficient pasteurization system design will result in an energy self-sufficient solution. Effluent should be safe for on-site land application. Means of further improving the water quality of the effluent will be investigated.


  1. Actively maintain our five existing ADPL systems, expand scope and quality of monitoring
  2. Redesign heater-heat exchanger system for improved efficiency
  3. Improve biogas production through better digester design
  4. Develop means to achieve superior effluent quality for reuse (other than direct land application)
  5. Work with partners towards integration of the ADPL concept, aim for STeP evaluation or extended demonstration of resulting product(s)

Research or implementation partners:

Eldoret, Kenya: Wataalamu Repair & Maintenance
Chennai, India: IIT Madras
Cebu Island, the Philippines: Tesari Foundation

Links, further readings – results to date:

Our website:
Documents in SuSanA library:

Current state of affairs:

Our website:

New Baffled Anaerobic Digesters For Eldoret ~ April, 2016

Two fixed dome anaerobic digesters designed by Aaron Forbis-Stokes using computational fluid dynamics were manufactured by Specialised Fibreglass in Nairobi and installed at the Eldoret North and Central sites. The new baffled design will improve average residence times and reduce solids in the effluent stream going into the heater and heat exchanger. The new digesters have four chambers and sampling ports for taking core samples and assessing solid deposition levels.

Biggest successes so far:

Installed new baffled digesters for improved solids retention, tipping buckets for flow rate measurement and Particle controller boards for more reliable control of heater temperatures and temperature monitoring in Eldoret, Kenya in April. Plans in place to roll these upgrades out in the Philippines and India this summer and early fall. Improved pasteurization system design underway.

Main challenges / frustration:

Managing suspended solids in the effluent, guaranteeing pasteurization holding times and temperatures during peak usage periods and consistently generating sufficient biogas to run the system on an ongoing basis.]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Fri, 15 Jul 2016 19:34:40 +0000
Re: South African Sanitation Technology Demonstration Programme (SASTEP) - BMGF-DST Partnership - by: swoolley PROJECT UPDATE:

200 EarthAugers have been assembled and are ready for new homes in Ida, Easter Cape. (Pic attached)

Most of the EarthAuger superstructures have been installed, with the EarthAuger units themselves now being installed into the superstructures. One owner has become quite attached to the unit before the toilet has arrived, personalising it with a different coat of paint. (pics attached).]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Fri, 15 Jul 2016 09:06:42 +0000
Re: The Nano Membrane Toilet - by: AParker
T. Onabanjo, K. Patchigolla, S.T. Wagland, B. Fidalgo, A. Kolios, E. McAdam, A. Parker, L.Williams, S. Tyrrel, E. Cartmell, Energy recovery from human faeces via gasification: A thermodynamic equilibrium modelling approach, Energy Conversion and Management 118:364-376

Non-sewered sanitary systems (NSS) are emerging as one of the solutions to poor sanitation because of the limitations of the conventional flush toilet. These new sanitary systems are expected to safely treat faecal waste and operate without external connections to a sewer, water supply or energy source. The Nano Membrane Toilet (NMT) is a unique domestic-scale sanitary solution currently being developed to treat human waste on-site. This toilet will employ a small-scale gasifier to convert human faeces into products of high energy value. This study investigated the suitability of human faeces as a feedstock for gasification. It quantified the recoverable exergy potential from human faeces and explored the optimal routes for thermal conversion, using a thermodynamic equilibrium model. Fresh human faeces were found to have approximately 70–82 wt.% moisture and 3–6 wt.% ash. Product gas resulting from a typical dry human faeces (0 wt.% moisture) had LHV and exergy values of 17.2 MJ/kg and 24 MJ/kg respectively at optimum equivalence ratio of 0.31, values that are comparable to wood biomass. For suitable conversion of moist faecal samples, near combustion operating conditions are required, if an external energy source is not supplied. This is however at 5% loss in the exergy value of the gas, provided both thermal heat and energy of the gas are recovered. This study shows that the maximum recoverable exergy potential from an average adult moist human faeces can be up to 15 MJ/kg, when the gasifier is operated at optimum equivalence ratio of 0.57, excluding heat losses, distribution or other losses that result from operational activities.]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Thu, 09 Jun 2016 17:09:51 +0000
“Sustainable sanitation uses the basic principles of nature to look for closing the cycles of water and nutrients, applying modern, sustainable and safe technologies”.

A careful analysis of the value chain identifies opportunities for inclusive development, therefore it is vital to promote effective dialogue between stakeholders, which helps to identify the "limitations and opportunities" and, at the same time facilitates partnerships between private sector and public institutions.
In this chain approach, the facilitator of process (SNV) plays a key role in the development of value chains - as a mediator between stakeholders- generating knowledge, advising the different actors of the chain and, more frequently, facilitating articulation of the links for a proper execution of processes along the chain.
The goal will always be to strengthen links so as to achieve self-sustainability of systems. An important part of this process is, for instance, improving access to finance of the most sensitive links, which without a proper chain approach and with no effective coordination, could not access traditional financing offers as stakeholders (or links) independent of the system. Finally, the value chain approach entails addressing institutional and governance aspects of the system to promote a favorable environment for their development.

Therefore, the value chain approach brings a useful tool to study and design specific interventions that strengthen the operation of a system providing basic services as sensitive to human development as it is sanitation. In particular, Decentralized Sustainable Sanitation (DSS), analyzed from the chain approach, is configured as a system of multiple stakeholders, tasks, services and –hence- links.

DSS, by its nature, requires a vision that not only assess the integrity of the system, but also that each stage of sanitation, sustainability and growth can be studied, both from their approach to access to basic services, as well as from their perspective of sustainable solution for ecological sanitation .

It is relevant to point out that the concept of sustainability is broad and also refers to environmental sustainability, under two perspectives: i) negative effects which cause an accelerated reduction of water sources; ii) the negative effects caused by improper handling and disposal of excreta are deposited directly on the ground without any treatment. To do this, DSS systems are characterized by the minimum and effective use of water resources.

As it can be seen from this brief reference to the DSS and ecological sanitation, the topic at hand is, from every point of view, an enabling setting for analysis from the perspective of value chain.

Providing safe and sustainable sanitation services to people means more than simply provide a latrine or toilet. Indeed this approach has often failed. Instead, the DSS means understanding the contexts in which poor people live and how businesses (or cooperative) and local government are investing in developing opportunities along the entire value chain sanitation. Therefore from our approach the chain does not begin with the collection and storage of human excreta, but rather begins long before with a social process (if not economic) of self-conviction of the need to transform the traditional practices of latrines, septic tanks or open field use (all of which are harmful to health and the environment) for a more efficient, ecological and sustainable innovative system.

In the light of these considerations, we are able to describe the DSS value chain, which has been developed in Bolivia in recent years, taking as a study case the Composting Dry Toilets integrated to some collection, transport, processing and waste recycling systems.

This table and graphical representation (Figure 1) shows that the sanitation chain is a sequence -more or less- organized activities in which different stakeholders can participate at each level (or link) and also various actors along the chain. That is to say in an analysis of industrial organization (basic sanitation industry) is perfectly possible that the process becomes progressively more efficient as technology improves (in each link) and market incentives are incorporated.

Thus for example, where different suppliers and consumers of service along the chain, can create incentives for process improvement gains in efficiency, improved quality and fundamentally sustainability of the entire system.

If in the DSS sanitation industry, with Eco Dry Toilets technology interconnected by a collection, transport, treatment and reuse of waste system there would be a single operator, may occur cross subsidies schemes permanently -among links- and also opportunities for service improvement could not be displayed correctly. In a –theoretical- scheme as the Figure 2 is possible to visualize the features of supply and demand for each link and, consequently, to maximize efficiency.

If on the contrary, in the analysis of the entire chain and its parts, we find that sustainability were at risk by technological features (e.g., high system infrastructure costs), we can find and justify the existing advantages in market integration at different levels

This market analysis-but also the analysis of processes and institutional arrangements present in DSS- is accomplished if the system is correctly displayed as a value chain; where, in the absence of sufficient market incentives, a facilitator as SNV is a key agent to promote that stakeholders of the chain are located and establish steady relationships to enable the development and consolidation of the DSS system as a strategic response to conventional sanitation system.]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Wed, 08 Jun 2016 20:15:10 +0000
Re: South African Sanitation Technology Demonstration Programme (SASTEP) - BMGF-DST Partnership - by: swoolley The SASTEP EarthAuger implementation is well underway, and more than half of the 200 units are now on the ground!

The superstructure used in this demonstration is a prefabricated concrete superstructure, developed by Rocla, and takes approximately 20 minutes to erect.

Dr Chuck Henry and myself were documenting the implementation, and will have several videos demonstrating how accessible this dignified sanitation solution is to implement in rural areas. However, a rough video on the installation of the superstructure is already available:

Dr. Chuck Henry, the developer of the Earth Auger, also discusses the unit here:;limit=1000#18162]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Tue, 07 Jun 2016 10:08:26 +0000
Re: Sustainable Decentralized Wastewater Management in Developing Countries (AIT, Thailand) - by: F H Mughal Four Innovative Environment Friendly Sanitation Products

According to the AIT June 2016 Newsletter, available at:, and at: , the AIT (Bangkok-based Asian Institute of Technology), officially launched four innovative environment friendly sanitation products, that AIT experts believe would help Thailand take the lead in improving the quality of life in both Asia and Africa, where they will be implemented.

Dr. Thammarat Koottatep, the Principal Investigator of the project said: “The idea is to have an on-site treatment that is decentralized so that we can avoid transportation of fecal matter over long distances.” He said that these products will help establish Thailand as a leader in water and sanitation technologies in the entire ASEAN region and beyond.

These four projects are: a sanitation truck that cleans all sludge; a cyclone toilet that uses gravity for cleaning; a pit that treats sludge before discharging it to the environment; and a solar toilet.

The innovative products were unveiled at AIT on 26 May 2016. The four technology products are the result of a five-year project titled “Reinventing the Toilet” that was funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

Dr. Doulay Koné, Deputy Director, Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation remarked: “AIT has done an excellent job, and now that the technology is ready, we are eagerly looking forward towards its implementation in both Asia and Africa.”

What are these four products (technologies)? Perhaps, Dr. Thammarat Koottatep may like to highlight these four technologies, in great details, on this forum.

F H Mughal]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Mon, 06 Jun 2016 04:43:24 +0000
Decentralised sustainable sanitation and gender mainstreaming in Sucre, Bolivia - by: mayala]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Wed, 01 Jun 2016 20:09:57 +0000
Re: South African Sanitation Technology Demonstration Programme (SASTEP) - BMGF-DST Partnership - by: SudhirPillay Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Fri, 27 May 2016 09:09:52 +0000 Re: Reinvent the Toilet Challenge - China Regional Program - Introduction and update on progress - by: zifuli
To your questions:
1. Yes, the targeted groups are the people of Africa and south Asia.
2. Yes, the selection committee tried to select the proposals which could meet the criteria for RTTC based on the priority of innovative tech., safety, "off the grid", economic aspect, etc.
3. It is planned that some of prototypes will be tested and demonstrated in Africa at the end of this year.

Best greetings

Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Wed, 11 May 2016 01:19:11 +0000
Re: The Nano Membrane Toilet - by: AParker
Thanks for your interest in the Nano Membrane Toilet. It's not actually so different, really the main thing is the addition of the gasifier and pelletiser.

The ash will be disposed of with the household solid waste - and of course there will be a way of releasing it form the gasifier. The design is still under development so this is just representative!

You're welcome to use the text on the front page of our website for your article:

Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Mon, 09 May 2016 08:51:43 +0000
Re: The Nano Membrane Toilet - by: mwaniki
Thanks for publishing the modified diagram of the nano membrane toilet. This version is very different from the one that was reported in the Africa Water, Sanitation & Hygiene Jan – Feb 2016 edition.

However, am curious to ask what happens to the ash after the waste is turned into energy in the gasifier. I can’t see any release screw underneath the chamber.

And if you could kindly let us have the accompanying text (maybe 200 words or thereabout), we could reprint it in the oncoming edition of the above publication for the benefit of our audience.

Regards / Mwaniki]]>
Processing technologies for excreta or faecal sludge Sat, 07 May 2016 01:48:50 +0000